Three problems with Ukrainian lobbying: weak fines, gray schemes, and "new old" players

In September, the "Lobbying Law," demanded by Western partners, came into force . This is how the US began regulating lobbyists to limit the influence of Nazi German propagandists. Who are these Ukrainian lobbyists?

lobbying, lobbying law, lobbyists

© Collage, ZN.UA

When Russia tried to influence the results of the elections in the United States, the senators there celebrated, that legislation regulating lobbying has become more relevant in America than ever before, writes Yuri Melnik
lawyer and participant of the Golka initiative on the website ZN.

For Ukraine, the issue of national security is also of paramount importance. However, lobbying is regulated not only to strengthen national security. Now that Ukraine is receiving significant funds for reconstruction, the new law should change the rules of interaction between business and government and transform the concept of "lobbying," currently perceived as shadowy deals and the behind-the-scenes influence of oligarchic clans, into a civilized, transparent, and accountable mechanism.

Unscrupulous businesses can pay politicians in cash if MPs regularly serve them and submit amendments they require. The media has repeatedly reported that the " Kolomoisky group ," " Akhmetov group ," " Pavlyuk group ," and other influence groups operate in parliament. These groups lobby for the interests of millionaire businessmen, and the fines for failure to register are extremely small—less than 2000 hryvnias. If a lobbyist violates the rules, the fine can reach 34 hryvnias. In other words, it's cheaper not to register.

DOSSIER : Ilya Pavlyuk: The Servant of the People Customs Mafia. PART 1

The public initiative "Golka" investigated the first hundred registered lobbyists and the new law to determine whether it has truly resolved the problem of shadow lobbying.

Ukraine's Lobbyists: New Players

It would seem that large developers, who have repeatedly attempted to lobby for favorable rules of the game through parliament, in particular through the influence of the "Kolomoisky group" and former representatives of the Opposition Platform - For Life party, should have been among the first to be included in the Transparency Register —the official list of lobbyists controlled by the National Anti-Corruption Agency (NAPC).

But they're nowhere to be seen now. Neither are the Moscow Patriarchate lobbyists, despite their subversive activities in the Verkhovna Rada. However, the civil society sector has already noted that lawyers who represented controversial politicians—Yanukovych and Kiva—were among the first to register. They're already actively developing this approach and have created the Higher School of Lobbying, as well as a separate committee within the National Bar Association of Ukraine—all of which will strengthen their influence on the political system. These same lawyers lobbied for the 12320 project , which undermines freedom of speech, back in the summer ( the results of the roll-call vote can be found in the " You Can Recharge the Country " tool ).

The lobbyist registry currently includes 94 lobbying entities. The most popular lobbying areas are economic development, legal, financial, tax, and customs policies.

Those who are not on the register are prohibited from lobbying.

Major retail chains such as Aurora and Metro, the state-owned Oschadbank, and representatives of the agricultural and energy sectors have already become official lobbyists . Major tobacco lobbyists , such as Philip Morris Ukraine and British American Tobacco Sales and Marketing Ukraine, are also involved. Previously, healthy lifestyle advocates had spent years fighting these shady attempts to influence legislation.

The Ukrainian Wind Energy Association is also already on the register. Parliament is currently actively promoting amendments to the law that would allow windmills to be built in the Carpathians without an environmental impact assessment ( here are the results of the roll-call vote for the relevant amendment ).

windmills, Runa glade

Construction of windmills on the Runa meadow // Ukrainian Environmental Protection Group

Useless fines

The ideology of the Ukrainian law is based on the European model, where lobbying is viewed not as evil but as a legitimate tool of democracy. Abroad, lobbyists work for businesses and conduct public campaigns to push for legislative changes. Everyone understands that they are paid by businesses for this, and this is a visible activity.

According to the authors, the law should create a more level playing field for businesses by providing a legal channel of communication with the government not only for large but also for medium-sized players. Ideally, this should improve the quality of the legislation itself, as it will be adopted taking into account the views and expertise of stakeholders.

Currently, according to the law, businesses wishing to lobby their interests must enter into a contract with a lobbyist. The lobbyist enters information about themselves and their clients into a registry and records their meetings and calls with officials. Every six months, they submit a report on their activities, sources and amounts of funding, and performance. Failure to comply with these requirements entails fines of up to 34 hryvnias.


Subscribe to our X channel , Telegram channel and Facebook page!

Stay informed about who is doing business, in politics, and supporting corruption in Ukraine!


The amount of the fine depends on the violation:

  • lobbying without registration - a fine from 850 to 1700 UAH;
  • failure to submit or late submission of a lobbying report to the Transparency Register – a fine from 850 to 1700 UAH;
  • Repeated violation (within a year) – ban on lobbying activities for up to one year, as well as a fine from 3400 to 8500 UAH;
  • failure to provide information about the existence of circumstances that preclude the possibility of being a subject of lobbying - a fine from 8500 to 17 thousand UAH;
  • Violation of restrictions regarding the subject of lobbying, beneficiaries, or funding of lobbying from illegal sources—a fine of 17 to 34 UAH.

Of all the fines, the most attention should be paid to lobbying without registration. Given the burden of duties and the risk of sanctions from the NACP facing official lobbyists, those who wish to remain in the gray zone will not be sufficiently motivated to register as lobbyists and renounce their shadow (corrupt) influence. This was emphasized by the Main Scientific and Expert Directorate of the Verkhovna Rada.

Moreover, the equal level of fines for individuals and legal entities puts them at a disadvantage, as large corporations have significantly greater financial resources. And not every public organization has the extra budgetary funds for such expenses. All this could contribute to the creation of a separate, closed caste of lobbyists, with law-abiding citizens, businesses, and public organizations forced to pay these lobbyists to protect their rights and put forward proposals.

The Main Scientific and Expert Directorate of the Verkhovna Rada Office warned about this in its comments on the first version of draft law No. 3059 , which was submitted by people's deputies from Batkivshchyna Yulia Tymoshenko and Sergey Vlasenko.

It's also worth recalling that Vlasenko submitted a very interesting amendment to the law "On Lobbying." It addressed advocacy—a term used by public organizations to influence government bodies to support or block policies deemed socially beneficial or harmful, according to public sector experts. In this amendment, Vlasenko noted that the term "advocacy" was coined by public organizations to avoid being listed as lobbyists. However, the amendment was rejected.

Indeed, currently, public organizations may choose not to list themselves in the Transparency Register. However, this would put the public sector, which conducts advocacy, at a disadvantage compared to lobbyists, whom committee members are required to hear. To achieve equal opportunities, public organizations would have to register and submit reports to the NAPC.

Lobbyists: Old Players and Schemes

Despite the fact that the proposed law was adopted at the request of Western partners, in two months it has had almost no impact on the situation currently prevailing in the parliamentary session hall.

During wartime, developers must lobby for the right reconstruction rules for their businesses. And there's a risk of cartels emerging, where players in the same business sector negotiate terms that allow them to create rules that allow them to reap excess profits.

The newly created registry currently doesn't list companies whose interests are served by lobbying groups repeatedly reported on by various media outlets: the "Kolomoisky group," which blocked the "anti-Kolomoisky law" with spam amendments, or representatives of the "Yanukovych-era smuggling king"—the "Pavlyuk group." Business partners of the "Akhmetov group" are also not yet visible. Although their influence on legislative activity is obvious.

A striking example is the urban development reform ( Project 5655 ), promoted by Olena Shulyak, head of the Servant of the People party . No less controversial is the adopted law "on strengthening the protection of the rights of bona fide purchasers," dubbed the " Igor Mazepa Law " in the media ( Project 12089 ). It was criticized by the European Parliament, which sees in it a significant risk of legalizing land stolen from the state. The law was promoted by MP Igor Fris (Servant of the People), and lobbyists spent considerable resources on an information campaign both in anonymous Telegram channels and in media outlets on the "white list" (media that the civil society determines are worthy of public trust).

DOSSIER : Elena Shulyak: From auditor of the "steel Jews" to figurehead of "Servant of the People." PART 1

Golka, Igor Mazepa, media attitude

Public initiative "Golka"

Some media outlets didn't label this content as advertising, giving lobbyists the opportunity to influence public opinion. Incidentally, these media outlets aren't listed as lobbyists, and oligarchs can take advantage of this.

DOSSIER : Igor Mazepa: Investment Shark or "Disguised Millionaire," Con Man and Cultist. PART 1

Currently, according to the law, not every member of parliament can be called a lobbyist because they are not registered. However, many elected officials, such as Petro Poroshenko , Vadym Stolar , Hryhoriy Surkis , Oleksandr Feldman , and others, are either founders of businesses or have a stake in them.

But according to the law, members of parliament are the target of lobbying, and therefore cannot effectively be lobbyists. Therefore, the section concerning members of parliament should have been drafted more clearly.

It's unclear what a lawmaker should do if a business owner is a family partner or relative. Could spending time with a wife, discussing her business issues, or having dinner with her mother fall under the definition of a "meeting with a potential lobbyist" that the lawmaker must report?

A similar question can be asked about the assistants to members of parliament, of whom there were more than six thousand in 2024. And among them, journalists have discovered relatives of deputies.

The NACP is supposed to monitor such contacts. However, the question remains whether the agency has the institutional capacity to monitor and prosecute violators.

And this is far from the only challenge. Yes, the law regulates exclusively lobbying for regulatory acts, while local authorities can adopt individual acts, and this creates a window of opportunity for developers.

Therefore, even after a year of the lobbyist registry's existence, the public will only see those who have decided to play by the rules or simply want to enter this services market as a new player, while the shadow players and their agreements will remain hidden from voters behind the scenes.

Skelet.Org

On the topic : The Ukrainian representative to the IAEA, linked to Derkach, spoke out against the use of American nuclear fuel in Ukraine.

Deputy Zablotsky from the Servant of the People party decided to use the Dmitry Natalukha Committee to lobby for his own project, which had not found support in another committee.

Lobbying under the guise of humanism: How deputies reduced fines for those who failed to supply weapons to the front.

lobbyists / lobbyists

Add a comment

Subscribe to our channels on Telegram, Facebook , Twitter , VK - Only new faces from the SKLEP section!